P&P
PAST & PURPOSENEWS · HISTORY · AUDIO

PAST & PURPOSE · WAR & POWER

They Won the War.
Then Feared Each Other.

How the defeat of Nazi Germany helped create NATO—and a confrontation that outlived the Soviet Union.

By Past & Purpose14 min read1945—Today
ALLIES1945VICTORY
THE PEACE DIVIDES
ATLANTIC ALLIANCE1949NATO

In 1945, the Western Allies and the Soviet Union emerged victorious from the same war.

Four years later, Western governments formed an alliance intended, in large part, to deter Soviet expansion.

Between those two moments lies the beginning of NATO.

Its story starts with an uncomfortable question: what happens when the enemy holding an alliance together disappears?

01

1945 · THE SETTLEMENT

Victory left a question nobody could settle

Defeating Hitler gave the wartime Allies a shared objective. It did not give them a shared vision of the peace.

Who would govern Germany? Which political systems would emerge across Europe? How much influence would Moscow exercise beyond Soviet borders? And would the United States remain committed to European security?

These became disputes over armies, governments, territory, and economic recovery. Germany’s occupation became a particular source of confrontation. The Western powers and the Soviet Union increasingly pursued incompatible arrangements for its future.

The war had ended. The struggle over the settlement had begun.

02

1948–1949 · BERLIN

The city that made distrust concrete

In June 1948, Soviet authorities cut the Western sectors of Berlin off from their land supply routes.

Berlin lay inside the Soviet occupation zone, but the city itself was divided among the victorious powers. Its geography made the Western presence vulnerable.

The Western Allies answered with an airlift, supplying the city rather than abandoning it or forcing their way through by land. The blockade continued until May 1949. NATO was founded while the crisis was still unfolding.

The confrontation made an abstract fear tangible. Western governments could see how pressure might be applied without a conventional invasion. A city could be isolated. Access could become leverage. An unresolved occupation arrangement could turn into an international emergency.

Berlin helped make a permanent security commitment seem urgent.

JUNE 1948BLOCKADE
APRIL 1949NATO
MAY 1949ACCESS RESTORED

03

FEAR, POWER & IDEOLOGY

Why “hatred of Russia” misses the mechanism

Anti-communism and hostility toward Soviet leadership were part of the atmosphere. But describing NATO as a product of hatred alone leaves out the decisions that created it.

Western governments feared Soviet power and the spread of communist control. The communist takeover in Czechoslovakia in 1948 intensified those concerns. Economic weakness also made political instability seem dangerous.

European governments wanted collective protection. American officials wanted a stronger Western Europe and a lasting connection between its security and the United States.

These were strategic interests as well as ideological convictions.

There is also a crucial difference between opposing a government’s policies and hating its people. NATO’s founding security problem concerned the power and behaviour of the Soviet state.

THE SHARPER HISTORICAL ARGUMENTNATO grew from the breakdown of wartime cooperation, the fear of Soviet expansion, and the search for a stable postwar Europe.

04

4 APRIL 1949 · THE TREATY

An alliance facing two dangerous futures

On 4 April 1949, twelve countries signed the North Atlantic Treaty.

Its central commitment treated an armed attack against one member as an attack against all. Each member would assist by taking the action it considered necessary, which could include armed force. That wording created a collective obligation without prescribing an identical military response from every country.

The alliance addressed more than the Soviet threat.

NATO’s own historical account identifies three purposes: deterring Soviet expansion, preventing a revival of nationalist militarism in Europe through a strong North American presence, and encouraging European political integration.

That makes NATO a direct product of the Second World War’s aftermath. Its founders were trying to manage both the confrontation taking shape and the destructive European politics they had just survived.

01

Deter expansion

Make an attack on one member a problem for the entire alliance.

02

Contain militarism

Keep North America engaged in European security.

03

Integrate Europe

Build political cooperation alongside military defence.

05

1955 · TWO BLOCS

Germany changed sides—and Europe hardened into blocs

West Germany entered NATO in 1955. The country whose defeat had united the wartime Allies was now becoming part of the Western alliance.

That same month, the Soviet Union and several Eastern European states established the Warsaw Pact. West German rearmament and NATO membership were immediate catalysts. The pact also formalised Soviet military influence over its Eastern European partners.

The division of Europe now had opposing alliance structures.

For Moscow, Western military integration raised fears about the balance of power. For countries under Soviet influence, Moscow’s version of security could mean restrictions on their own independence.

The Warsaw Pact’s later use in interventions against dissent—including Czechoslovakia in 1968—showed that its purpose extended beyond defending against an outside attack.

Security for a powerful state could become control over its neighbours.

WESTNATONorth American presence
Collective defence
EUROPE
DIVIDED
EASTWARSAW PACTSoviet military influence
Alliance control

06

1991 · AFTER THE USSR

The Soviet Union disappeared. NATO stayed.

The end of the Cold War created a new question: what was an alliance built partly around deterring Soviet power supposed to do after that power collapsed?

NATO survived, pursued new partnerships, and admitted additional members. Its relationship with Russia included attempts at cooperation alongside growing disagreements.

Expansion became particularly contentious.

Declassified records show that Western leaders offered Soviet officials assurances about NATO’s eastward reach during the negotiations surrounding German reunification in 1990. The scope and lasting significance of those assurances remain disputed. They should neither be erased from the record nor casually described as a binding treaty prohibition on all future enlargement.

There was also a question that discussions between major powers could overlook: what choices should the countries between them be allowed to make?

In the 1997 NATO–Russia Founding Act, both sides endorsed respect for states’ sovereignty and their right to choose how to provide for their own security. They also committed to consultation, cooperation, and restraint.

The confrontation was not uninterrupted. A different relationship was attempted.

07

2014–2022 · THE BREAK

The break that brought the rivalry back

Russia’s annexation of Crimea in 2014 marked a major rupture. NATO suspended practical civilian and military cooperation with Russia.

Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022 deepened the confrontation.

These events belong to a different political world from 1949. Modern Russia is not Stalin’s Soviet Union, and today’s NATO has developed far beyond its original membership and structure.

Yet the historical connection remains: European security still turns on borders, alliances, sovereignty, and fears about what neighbouring powers might do.

THE ENDURING QUESTION

The peace that never became a shared settlement

NATO is a by-product of the end of the Second World War—but the missing ingredient was a peace settlement the victorious powers could sustain together.

They defeated the same enemy.
They disagreed about the order that should replace him.

Fear became policy. Policy became an alliance. The alliance endured after its original adversary disappeared.

The tragedy is that winning a war can settle who has been defeated without settling how the victors will live together afterward.